Morningland Dairy 1st Day in Court–Update

Doreen Hannes

January 11, 2011

Today was Morningland Dairy’s first day in court. Getting into the court room was almost like trying to get on an airplane, except for no one ‘touched your junk’, and I didn’t see any naked scanners there. You simply couldn’t even bring in a purse, laptop, cell phone or bottle of water.  The law enforcement monitoring entry seemed to ease up a bit as the day wore on, but at first it was pretty durn tense out in the entry area.

Roughly forty five people were in the audience, and it filled the little spectator’s vestibule in the Howell County Missouri Court House.  The unusual number in the audience drew Judge Dunlap’s attention and he commented upon it during his opening instructions on proper court room decorum.  The presence of so many people  on a very cold day when all area schools were closed because of questionable roads illustrates the importance of this case to the residents of South Central Missouri.

While this is just a small update for those who have been supportive of the dairy, there is a tremendous amount of detail that was covered in the testimony given today. The majority of the day was taken up with the testimony of Gene Wiseman, Executive Secretary of the Missouri Milk Board, and Don Falls, Environmental Specialist and lead Missouri Milk Board investigator and inspector of Morningland Dairy plant.

In my opinion, Gary Cox, attorney for Morningland from Farm to Consumer Legal Defense Fund, did a pretty good job on cross-examination. As many of you know, I have been somewhat critical of Mr. Cox in the past, and I simply want to give credit where credit is due.  He did a good job today. So, a hat tip to Gary Cox is in order, and I will give it!

Wiseman stated that he ordered an embargo on Morningland Dairy’s cheese without any actual knowledge of contamination. That he had never scheduled a destruction date with Morningland, and that the State of Missouri had assumed all FDA documents, except for the one Cox showed him about investigations of dairy facilities. There is no state statute or regulation that categorically states that Missouri has accepted and adopted all FDA guidelines or standards….and the Attorney General’s office tried to disallow questioning about the FDA as hearsay. But since Don Falls worked with the FDA on their investigation of Morningland, it was allowed after all.

Judge Dunlap is rather unorthodox in his courtroom manner. Initially I thought he was entirely too helpful and lenient with the Attorney General’s office. I have never seen a Judge help to rephrase counsel’s questions after objection in the way that he did.  But he showed the same latitude with Mr. Cox’s cross examination, so I think it is just his demeanor and it wasn’t apparent to me that he was showing bias in favor of the prosecution. Additionally, his questions for his clarification of the two Missouri Milk Board witnesses were germane, intelligent, and astute. So it doesn’t appear on its face that we are actually dealing with a foregone conclusion in favor of the State in this case.

All  who are able to attend the trial in the morning, (9am Central) just a few hours from this writing, are encouraged to do so.  While the pace of today’s proceedings seems to indicate that the trial would have to continue into Thursday, it is scheduled to wrap up on Wednesday the 12th of January, 2010. All who attended today are deeply appreciated!

I will do  a more thorough overview of the court case itself in the next couple of days, but not being allowed a laptop for note taking purposes makes this part of my job a little more difficult! Just remember, if you come to the Howell County Court House, leave everything outside in your car except for your keys. You can put those in the little bucket and walk through the detector.


8 responses to “Morningland Dairy 1st Day in Court–Update

  1. Thank you very much, Doreen. Thank you for being there, thank you for reporting. I know that I am not the only one that is grateful.

  2. Thank you for this report. My breath ws baited all day yesterday. My prayers are with you all: the Dixons, the cows, your customers, your family. You prevail!

  3. I live in Austin, Texas but would have definitely been at this Court House if I lived in WI. I sent out emails to over 40 of my email contacts to send a donation to this cause. The final ruling in this case will set a precedent for how the other small dairy farmers in this country fare going up against these corrupt, big money Industrial Farmers, (namely “Monsanto”) the corrupt FDA, and the corrupt American Dairy Association who fund and manipulate these Govt. organizations. May you prevail and set the precedent that it is indeed possible for the small farmers across this Country to stand up against Goliath and win. In the end, may you have an even more successful farming business than you could ever have anticipated before this ordeal.

  4. is it possible you may be able to obtain a copy of the court stenographers’ notes and publish them here?

    • Perhaps. That’s a good point, Chris. I’ll ask Doreen when I talk to her tonight.

    • They do audio recordings these days and it costs a lot of $$ to get the court records. Because it was over 20 hours of testimony and examination, it would take up copious amounts of space to duplicate those records here. For our raw milk hearing, it cost us nearly $100 to get our records and it was less than 4 hours on the record. I believe that the attorney’s motions would be public record. It might be possible to obtains those, but there still would be a cost.

  5. Pingback: Update! Morningland Dairy Goes to Court for Contempt of Court | Morningland Dairy's Uncheese Party

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s